In the battle of the Buffalo Wings Duff’s Famous Wings totally blows Anchor Bar away!
At least that’s my opinion, but you know what they say about a-holes and opinions. Also, my a-hole had nothing to do with my taste buds during this trip to upstate NY. I had a chance to try them both while in town for a few days recently. Both spots could not be anymore different. Much has been said regarding the Buffalo Wing supremacy when it comes to these two iconic bastions of wing debauchery. My vote goes to Duff’s!
Anchor bar is where you go as a tourist to say you ate wings at the place that invented them. It’s an old bar with great memorabilia and old motorcycles hanging on the walls. The dining area is straight out of some old Catskills looking joint and looks it’s age.
Duff’s is where the locals and people in the know go to chow down on better tasting meatier wings where they have improved on the original recipe. The dining area is brighter and cleaner looking with just some old framed black and whites on the walls showcasing it’s history. Even on a midweek evening the place was packed and there was a short wait but it was so worth it the moment I bit into one of those juicy tasty wings. The waitress we had was super nice and attentive even though you could see they were running around here like crazy with the full house.
I did like that they offered some nifty combo platters here that included a plate of 20 wings, a pitcher of soda, and a monster bowl of crispy fries for only $24 which I thought was a good deal, and perfect for two people to share. Of course, celery, carrots, and bleu cheese came with it. The wings here are fat, moist, and flavorful with just the right amount of crispiness the way we like them. Beware the wing sauces here as they are hot! We were pretty much stuffed after this gluttonous feast!
Go to Anchor Bar for the history, then go to Duff’s for a taste of better Buffalo Wings.
Duff’s Famous Wings – http://www.duffswings.com/
Being up in Buffalo for a few days you just know we had to do the touristy thing and check out the wings at Anchor Bar. Heck, it’s the birthplace of one of my favorite snacks when watching a game. Chicken wings! You just can’t go to Buffalo without hitting up the place that started it all. Unless you’re a vegan. Then don’t bother. Nothing here for you folks. More for us carnivores thank you very much!
It’s a great looking bar with a lot of history behind it. It does look it’s age. Plenty of pictures of major celebrities, sports stars, and dignitaries all over the walls. Memorabilia everywhere. Some great motorcycles are also displayed around the bar hung above. Very cool. It’s the kind of place American Pickers would love.
Plenty of seating with a few different dining rooms. This place is very deceiving from the outside. As with most touristy types of places there is even a souvenir shop in here with all kinds of swag – shirts, hats, etc. You just know a joint has jumped the shark when they install a souvenir store. The bathroom was kind of nasty and hot as a sauna. I guess it’s par the for course with these kind of old places. The service was ok if a bit on the slow side but our waitress was nice.
As for the main reason to come here – the wings. Eh, they were just ok. Decent sauce and the wings were a good size but cooked not as crispy as we requested. A bit pricey for what they offer but I figure you’re paying for the tourist factor of this spot. At least a pint of Labatt’s was only $3 which is a win in my book coming from overpriced NYC. As far as their wings go they are ok overall but at this point I have had better in many places around Manhattan where I live.
If visiting in town I guess you go here for the history and the fact just to say you ate wings at the place that started it all. A touristy “must do”.
Anchor Bar – http://anchorbar.com/
28 thoughts on “Buffalo Wing battle in upstate NY! Duff’s vs Anchor Bar.”
I like my wings so spicy that they make me fart sparks.
Explosive diarrhea for the win!
FILBIO!!!! Did you miss me as much as I missed you and your blog comments?
[Answer ‘no’ and there will be consequences. I’ll be lurking and waiting to pounce on your comments on those blogs we both frequent.]
Thanks for the heads up on the original bar. I don’t pay for touristy. I’ll spend my bucks where my taste buds will do a happy dance.
We made our own rockin’ good chicken wings last night. Grilled. Coated with Defcon sauce (Get it shipped from New Jersey, so you know it’s GOTTA be good.) & back on the grill to char that sauce. YUMMERS!!!!
Long time no see! How have you been? of course I missed you and your drunken naked escapades around my blog.
Well, if that sauce was made with NJ water I can understand if your ass shoots out flames after that!
Those wings from Duffs do look meatier and tastier than the OG wings at Anchors. You folks in NYC pay $24 for 20 wings, soda, and fries? Make that a pitcher of Guinness Stout and you might get that down here in downtown Houston…man, you guys get raped without even getting mugged up there!
Duff’s did have the better wings in opinion. Yes, it is cheaper to live in Houston. Those prices were also in upstate NY!
I get ‘saucy’ paying .50 per wing here for crappy one’s with even crappier sauce…Good thing here in H-town, we love food and are considered the dine-out capital, so options are plentiful and the competition for pricing is as stiff as …well, I cant say! lol
Here in Manhattan I have a few local pubs that do wing night so it is cheaper. Cheap beer and tasty wing Wednesday!
I looooovee good chicken wings! I like a place that the blue cheese and celery come with it. My mouth is watering for some crispy wings now.
They must come with a good bleu cheese and celery. Carrots too. We have a place close to us that does Wednesday wing night. I can’t wait!
I possess a longstanding penchant for buffalo wings. I’ve noted your preferences for the next time I’m in New York (probably next year).
Just make sure you’re up in Buffalo as that is where these were. I have had better right here in Manhattan!
Both great places, but the Bar Bill just outside Buffalo in East Aurora has my all-time favorite wings!
I met so many people that gave us tips on wing places up there. I need to go back and try them all!
Two things. First, it’s raining and cold here and I really, really wish I could make it to Duffs for wings. Second, I can’t tell you how relieved I am to hear of the lack of relationship between your a-hole and your taste buds. It means I can keep reading this blog.
Well, I’m glad we settled that. If I ate through my anus I guess this blog might not exist!
Now if only Duff”s delivered to Manhattan. Scotty – beam me over there!
Interesting Wing Tour. Love spicy chicken wings and wouldn’t mind making the taste test comparison some day! Hey, this reminds me its one dollar wing day at the bar around the corner, elevating my taste buds now.
I figured whike I was up there that I had to check out the two most famous wing joints in the town that started it all!
I want your social life. Can I join you on all these food excursions, please? Deliciousness. 🙂
Just be prepared to run a lot and hit the gym almost every day so as to not blow up to a monster size! It’s the price to pay….
I haven’t had wings in forever! Sounds like you are having a blast in New York! 🙂
Time to go out for some wings and beer! Buffalo was actually kind of fun!
Sounds like a good duel there Phil. I don’t know what it is exactly but you Americans all seem to love wings more than anything else. Everywhere I go people recommend “wings”.
I’ve only been to Buffalo once but I must admit to being pleasantly surprised about the place. Mind you I did go in the height of summer!
Yeah, we are little piggies here when it comes to our wings. It’s a matter of pride to know the best spots for them. Buffalo was pretty nice actually, but as you said, go in summer as winter is brutal there!
Now I am SERIOUSLY jonesin’ for some wings.
I am always jonesin’ for some tasty wings!
Hot wings are sacred to me! lol 😉 I love them & have childhood memories of my Uncles taking me to places for platters of spicy delight!! Whereas I differ from them, is I like the hot ones, but also love the sweet & tangy!! Mouth’s watering now. And then there’s the bleu cheese & celery!! Oh God how I love Bleu Chees & Celery! And there it goes. Every freaking time I visit your blog, I end up in the kitchen! lmao 😉 great post my friend, running to grab a bite to eat!! Ha 😛
I do love making women drool and have them aching for something to put in their mouths! Ohhhh Yesssss! 😉
I love chicken wings, and that blue cheese and celery. Just wish it was all fat free!